How to Reheat Pizza in Toaster Oven- Quick And Easy Guide

Ah, pizza. That delicious, gooey, cheesy, wonderful food that is so much better when it’s hot and fresh out of the oven. But what do you do if you have some leftover pizza and want to reheat it? Sure, you could put it in the microwave, but there’s an even better way – using a toaster oven! 

Why Is Reheated Pizza So Much Better?

It’s a mystery that has puzzled pizza lovers for centuries: why is reheated pizza so much better than the original? Could it be that its flavor improves with time like a fine wine, or could it be something more scientific? After some thorough research, we may have an answer. 

Turns out, it all comes down to the way the cheese interacts with the crust. When heated up, cheeses like mozzarella release their oils which causes them to become more gooey and flavorful, making for a cheesy pizza experience that just can’t be beaten. But why does this happen when reheating pizza that wasn’t originally prepared this way?

It turns out that the moisture in the crust works to bring out the flavor of the cheese, creating a delectable combination when heated up. When you heat up pizza for the first time, this interaction doesn’t quite happen because it hasn’t had enough time to set. 

But once you reheat it again and give it a good few minutes in a hot oven, the moisture in the crust and oils from the cheese combine to create a unique flavor that can’t be recreated any other way. 

So, next time you’re faced with a slice of yesterday’s pizza that still looks appetizing, don’t hesitate to heat it up! You may just find yourself pleasantly surprised by its delicious taste. Reheated pizza is truly a gift from the culinary gods.

How to Reheat Pizza in Toaster Oven

  • Step 1: Preheat your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. This will ensure that your pizza heats evenly and quickly without burning or becoming dried out. 
  • Step 2: Place your pizza onto an aluminum foil-lined baking sheet or directly on the rack inside the toaster oven. If you opt for the baking sheet route, make sure that you use one with sides so that any melted cheese doesn’t end up dripping down onto the bottom of your toaster oven. 
  •  Step 3: Bake for 5-10 minutes until the cheese is melted and bubbly and the crust is crunchy yet still slightly soft in texture. Keep a close eye on it as cooking times may differ depending on how much pizza you are trying to reheat.  
  • Step 4: Once finished baking, remove from the toaster oven and let cool for a few minutes before serving. Enjoy!


Is it safe to reheat pizza twice? 

While some might be tempted to heat up their leftovers again and again, the answer is: not really! Reheating pizza more than once can make the dough dry out, leaving you with a crispy crust that’s far from ideal. The cheese can also get rubbery, which is no fun either. 

So, if you want to get the most out of your leftovers, it’s best to reheat pizza just once and savor every delicious bite! 

Read more:

Long Slot Toaster Overviews: An In-Depth Look at the Most Popular Models

Toaster vs Toaster Oven: Which One Is Right for You?

Is There A Microwave Toaster Oven Combo? Pros and Cons 

What happens if you eat pizza left out overnight?

Eating pizza that’s been left out overnight is a risky move. It could taste great, or it could make you regret ever having the idea of eating cold pizza in the first place! 

While it won’t hurt you right away, there are risks associated with consuming food that has been sitting at room temperature for too long. 

Eating old pizza can lead to food poisoning, so it’s best to stick with freshly made pizza if you’re looking for a delicious meal. That said, some people swear by the taste of cold pizza and would never pass up the opportunity to indulge in a few slices. 

If you choose to take the risk, just be sure to keep an eye on any symptoms that might arise after eating. It’s better to be safe than sorry! 

Bottom line: Eating pizza that has been left out overnight can be risky, so unless you’re willing to take a gamble, it’s best to go for freshly made pizza instead. That way, you won’t have to worry about any nasty surprises!


So there you have it – four simple steps guaranteed to help you reheat your leftover pizza in a jiffy using nothing more than a trusty old toaster oven! Who knew something so deceptively simple could be so incredibly delicious? Be sure to experiment with various cooking times until you find the perfect balance between crunchy crust and melted cheese. Bon appétit!