If you believe that the best pizza does not always come from the most popular restaurant, you’ve come to the right place on the internet. Despite its modest size, Colusa, California, has a very sophisticated pizza scene. There are some hidden gems in town, whether you prefer a thin crust stuffed with vegetables, a family-sized meat combo, or a crispy pepperoni slice.
Let’s talk about local favorite pizza places that locals love but visitors might miss. Here are the best pizza spots in Colusa you might not know about—but absolutely should.
Table of Contents
1. Mountain Mike’s Pizza on McNulty Way
Location: Mountain Mike’s Pizza Colusa – McNulty Way
Famous for: Huge pepperoni slices, a family-friendly setting, and speedy takeout.
Let’s start by introducing you to Colusa’s Mountain Mike’s Pizza in Colusa, CA. Tucked on McNulty Way, this spot balances big flavors with even bigger community spirit. The crust? Crisp but chewy. The toppings? Generous. The signature pepperoni curl? Iconic.
The place offers more than pizza because it creates a welcoming atmosphere for customers from their initial visit.
If you’re craving bold flavors and a no-fuss experience, Mountain mike’s pizza colusa McNulty Way should be your first stop.
Why It Stands Out:
- Signature crispy curly pepperoni
- Online ordering & lightning-fast pickup
- Supports local events and school fundraisers
- Voted by local Facebook groups as one of Colusa’s greatest pizzas.
This is your sign if you haven’t tried Mountain Mike’s on McNulty Way yet.
2. Rico’s Pizza Parlor
Location: 12th St, Colusa
Known For: Old-school pies with a loyal following
Rico’s is the kind of pizzeria you hear about from your neighbor’s cousin; the definition of a hidden gem. Family-owned, no-frills, and unapologetically traditional, they serve up thick, cheesy slices that taste like the ‘90s in the best way.
It’s not fancy. You won’t find arugula on your pizza here. But what you will find is:
- Classic sausage and mushroom done right.
- A sauce with just the right kick.
- Prices that haven’t caught up with 2025 inflation.
Rico’s might fly under the radar, but regulars know; it’s comfort food at its finest.
3. Pete’s Pizza Wagon (Food Truck Fridays)
Location: Various (check Colusa’s weekly farmers market or Friday food truck rallies)
Known For: Fire-roasted pies, seasonal ingredients
Here’s a twist: a mobile pizza place that may be offering some of the best, freshest pizza in the area. The menu of Pete’s Pizza Wagon, which is wood-fired, is constantly changing to reflect what’s local and fresh.
On any given Friday, you might catch:
- Pesto chicken with garden basil
- Peach and prosciutto (yes, really)
- Spicy salami with hot honey drizzle
The crust is hand-stretched. The oven is real-deal firewood. And the lines? They move fast because Pete doesn’t mess around.
If you’re looking for pizza, Colusa CA locals chase around town, this one’s your must-try.
4. Bella Pizzeria and La Vita (inside Colusa Golf & Country Club)
Location: Country Club Rd
Known For: Gourmet pies in a surprisingly chill setting
Think golf clubs are only for putting? Think again. La Vita e Bella is an upscale, lesser-known eatery serving artisan pizzas inside Colusa’s Country Club, and you don’t need to be a member to stop in.
The pies are lean gourmet:
- Truffle oil mushroom
- Gorgonzola with caramelized onions
- Thin crust Margherita with house-pulled mozzarella
Perfect for client lunches, date nights, or anytime you want good pizza in a nicer setting.
Quick Comparison Table
| Pizzeria | Best For | Specialties | Vibe |
| Mountain Mike’s Colusa | Fast, crowd-pleasing classics | Curly pepperoni, combo pies, takeout deals | Family-friendly, fast |
| Rico’s Pizza Parlor | Nostalgic flavors, budget eats | Sausage-mushroom, cheese-loaded deep dish | Local haunt |
| Pete’s Pizza Wagon | Artisan, wood-fired freshness | Rotating seasonal specials | Food truck energy |
| La Vita e Bella Pizzeria | Gourmet, quiet escapes | Truffle mushroom, margherita | Upscale, relaxed |
So, Which One Should You Try First?
The Mountain Mike. Whether you’re new to Colusa or simply want to switch up your daily slice routine, Mike’s on McNulty Way is a great place to start. And when do you feel like impressing yourself or someone else? Pick Bella e La Vita.
One thing is certain, regardless of the place you visit: Mountain mike’s Colusa’s pizza scene is subtly amazing and worth discovering one slice at a time.
No matter your mood or toppings of choice, pizza Colusa CA options are surprisingly diverse for a town this size. From wood-fired wagons to gourmet country-club pies, you’ve got plenty to explore—and every bite tells a local story.
Final Bite
Pizza is a community staple in Colusa, California. There’s something here to satisfy any need, whether it’s a Friday night food truck find or a Tuesday night grab-and-go. Even though well-known chains have a place, these regional treasures are what add flavor.
You now understand where to go.
