Can You Put Uncrustables In The Toaster? Let’s Take A Look At What Happens

Uncrustables have become a lunchtime staple for kids and adults all over the world. But what happens when you throw caution to the wind and try toasting them up in your toaster? In this blog post, we’ll take an in-depth look into what actually happens when you put Uncrustables into a toaster, so grab some popcorn and keep reading!

Source: Practical Cook

Introduction: What Is an Uncrustable?

An Uncrustable is a pre-made, frozen sandwich that consists of peanut butter and jelly smushed together between two slices of bread. The sandwich is then wrapped in crust and flash-frozen. Uncrustables were created by the Smuckers Company in 1992 and became popular because they were a mess-free way to enjoy a PB&J sandwich. 

While the Smuckers Company does sell Uncrustables in select grocery stores, you can also find them in the frozen section of most major retailers, such as Walmart or Target. And if you’re lucky enough to have a Cracker Barrel restaurant near you, they sell them too!

Preparing the Uncrustables for Toasting

If you’re looking for a quick and easy snack, Uncrustables are a great option. But what if you’re in the mood for something warm and toasty? Can you put Uncrustables in the toaster?

Here’s what you need to know about putting Uncrustables in the toaster:

  1. First, remove the crust from the Uncrustable. You can do this by pressing down on the top of the sandwich with your thumb.
  2. Next, place the Uncrustable facedown on a piece of wax paper or foil.
  3. Put the wax paper or foil on a baking sheet, and then place the baking sheet in the toaster oven.
  4. Toast on low or medium heat until the Uncrustable is warm throughout (about 30 seconds to 1 minute).
  5. Enjoy your toasty Uncrustable!

Can You Actually Put Uncrustables in the Toaster?

The UncrustablesMerlin Menu has been a lifesaver for busy moms and dads alike. But can you actually put these little sandwiches in the toaster? Let’s take a look at what happens.

If you’ve ever tried to make your own Uncrustables, you know that getting the crusts off can be a real pain. That’s where the toaster comes in. Just pop your Uncrustables in the toaster and voila! No more crusts.

But what about the filling? Well, it turns out that the filling is pretty heat-resistant. So, if you’re careful, you can definitely put Uncrustables in the toaster without worry. Just be sure to watch them closely so they don’t burn.

So there you have it! You can indeed put Uncrustables in the toaster.

Read more:

How Much Carrot Juice Is Safe to Drink Daily? The Ultimate Guide

Long Slot Toaster Reviews: An In-Depth Look at the Most Popular Models

Toaster vs Toaster Oven: Which One Is Right for You?

The Results: What Happens When You Put Uncrustables in the Toaster

When you put an Uncrustable in the toaster, there are a few things that happen. The first is that the bread starts to toast. This makes the outside of the Uncrustable crispy and golden brown. The second thing that happens is that the peanut butter and jelly start to melt together. This creates a delicious, gooey filling that is even more delicious than the original Uncrustable. The third thing that happens is that the cheese starts to melt. This gives the Uncrustable a cheesy, creamy flavor that is simply irresistible.

Benefits of using the Toaster to Toast Uncrustables

When you’re in a hurry and don’t have time to make a PB&J from scratch, Uncrustables are a delicious and convenient option. But what if you’re feeling extra lazy and don’t even want to take the time to heat up your sandwich in the microwave? Can you just pop an Uncrustable in the toaster like you would with regular bread?

The short answer is yes, you can put Uncrustables in the toaster. And while it’s not exactly the same as heating up your sandwich in the microwave, it does have some benefits. For one thing, using the toaster will give your Uncrustable a slightly crispier crust. And if you’re someone who likes their PB&J on the crusty side, this is a great option.

Another benefit of using the toaster is that it will evenly distribute the heat throughout your sandwich. This means that all of the peanut butter and jelly will be nice and warm, rather than just one spot being hot and the rest being cold.

So if you’re looking for a quick and easy way to enjoy an Uncrustable, popping it in the toaster is definitely an option worth considering. Just be sure to keep an eye on it so that it doesn’t get too crispy!

Alternatives to Toasting Uncrustables

Assuming you don’t want to eat your Uncrustables cold, there are a few alternative methods for heating them up. One popular method is microwaving the sandwich for about 15-20 seconds. This will give you a warm, soft Uncrustable that’s pretty similar to the toaster version.

Another option is to place the Uncrustable on a grill or panini press. Just like with the toaster, you’ll want to use low heat so as not to burn the bread. Grill for about 30-60 seconds on each side, or until the bread is golden brown and warmed through.

Finally, you can always warm up your Uncrustables in a conventional oven. Just preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and place the sandwiches on a baking sheet for about 5-10 minutes. This method will give you a slightly crispier Uncrustable, but it’s still delicious!

If you eat UnCrustables you need to watch this.


Do Uncrustables go bad if not refrigerated?

If you’re like me, then you love a good Uncrustable. They’re pre-made sandwiches that come in their own little plastic wrappers, and they’re perfect for on-the-go snacking. But what happens if you don’t refrigerate them? Can you still eat them?

The short answer is yes, but there are a few things you should know before chowing down on an unrefrigerated Uncrustable. First of all, if the sandwich has been sitting out for more than two hours, it’s technically no longer safe to eat. However, if it’s only been a couple of hours and the sandwich doesn’t look or smell off, then it should be fine to eat.

Another thing to keep in mind is that unrefrigerated Uncrustables will not taste as fresh as they would if they were refrigerated. The bread will likely be a little stale and the peanut butter and jelly may not be as smooth and creamy. So if you’re looking for the optimal Uncrustable experience, it’s best to stick to the fridge.

Source: Spoon University

How long does Uncrustables last?

Uncrustables are made with real bread and filled with delicious ingredients, so they’re perfect for a quick and easy snack. But how long do they last?

The short answer is that Uncrustables will last for about two days when stored at room temperature. But if you’re looking to keep them fresh for longer, there are a few things you can do.

First, make sure to store your Uncrustables in a cool, dry place. If they’re stored in a warm or humid environment, they won’t last as long.

Second, don’t open the package until you’re ready to eat them. Once the package is open, the bread will start to stale quickly.

And finally, if you want your Uncrustables to taste fresh and delicious for as long as possible, pop them in the fridge! They’ll last for up to a week when stored in the fridge (but we bet they won’t stick around that long!)


To wrap up, while it may be tempting to put Uncrustables in the toaster out of convenience and curiosity, it’s definitely not something we’d recommend. With the risk of dangerous situations and a lack of desirable results, there are much better ways to heat your Uncrustables than using a toaster. Instead, stick with ovens or microwaves for heating up your favorite Uncrustable sandwiches for lunch!